Thursday, 19 November 2026

Discovering Iain Hamilton (1922-2000) Part III

There is currently no biography or monograph dedicated to the life, times and achievement of Iain Hamilton. That said, there is plenty of information available to the interested listener. A good start is with several reference books. The entry in the current Grove’s Dictionary of Music and Musicians was published 21 years ago and gives short shrift to this major British composer. It does provide a works list, and a basic bibliography. Equally dated are the on-line entries in the National Biography (2004) and Who Was Who (2007). That said, they give an interesting summary of Hamilton’s career.

An excellent place to begin study is with Murray Schafer’s British Composers in Interview, (London, Faber & Faber) published in 1963. Along with a host of big names, Hamilton is presented in an interesting and revealing interview. A lengthy and often quixotic study was made by David C.F. Wright, which, despite some characteristic eccentricities and digressions, presents some useful information. It is currently hard to find on the Internet.

There is a major essay by Paul Conway at MusicWeb International which is in the form of an extended obituary, with detailed discussions of several compositions. It is the most thorough overview presently available.

There are currently two theses accessible, one of which examines Hamilton’s contribution to the clarinet repertoire, and the other is an analysis of his Palinodes for piano solo.

On the other hand, there are a wealth of articles, reviews, and obituaries available in journals, newspapers and online. In addition to these, there are many articles written by the composer, which certainly build up a picture of his musical ethos.

Possible Works to Revive?
It is often disingenuous for an enthusiast of an artist to suggest what ought to be revived and/or recorded. There will always be the danger that they will propose “everything” – the Complete Works. There is little chance that this will ever happen with Iain Hamilton. A possible compromise would be a recording of the symphonic cycle. This has been done by CPO Records for several less-well-known 20th century British composers such as Benjamin Frankel, Egon Wellesz and Humphrey Searle. It would be ideal if the English Music Festival could perform one of Hamilton’s lighter orchestral scores such as the Bartholomew Fair Overture, the 1912: Overture or the Ecossaise for orchestra. More improbably, would be a revival of one of the operas. Although performances of The Royal Hunt of the Sun, The Cataline Conspiracy and Anna Karenina have been given, there are operas that have yet to be premiered. It may be possible for a CD/download of this last named to be generated from the 1981 BBC live broadcast.
A persuasive case can be made for a recording of the complete organ works. Threnos – In time of War was written in the United States in 1966, reflecting on Hamilton’s thoughts about the Vietnam War. He uses “unorthodox” performing methods here, including chromatic clusters on the pedals and manuals. Other organ pieces including Aubade, Roman Music, Fanfares and Variants, and A Vision of Canopus could be accommodated on a single CD.

Conclusion
It seems ironic that the BBC did not include any music by Iain Hamilton in the 2022 Promenade Concert Series. At least, they could have featured one of his lighter pieces such as the Concerto for Jazz Trumpet or the Scottish Dances. Searching the Newsbank on-line database discloses no reports or intimations of any recitals or concerts, so far, this year. (As of 28 September 2022). Even the Glasgow Herald, did not see fit to acknowledge Hamilton’s Centenary. The BBC Symphony Orchestra have programmed a performance of the Clarinet Concerto on 20 April 2023, at the City Halls, Glasgow. The soloist was Robert Plane. Just a year too late.

Concluded

This essay was first printed in the 2024 edition of Spirited, the Journal of the English Music Festival.

Monday, 16 November 2026

Discovering Iain Hamilton (1922-2000) Part II

Any assessment of Hamilton’s oeuvre is severely restricted by the lack of recordings and present-day concert and recital performances. The notes below typically reflect what the interested listener can actually hear on CD/stream. I have included a few comments on the operas, none of which have been commercially recorded.

Iain Hamilton’s catalogue is wide ranging, and includes operas, four symphonies, numerous concertos, orchestral works, chamber, piano and organ music. Stylistically, his exemplars were Bartók, Stravinsky, Schoenberg and later Anton Webern. Yet, Hamilton evolved his own style, synthesising serialism, non-tonal structures and various degrees of dissonance. In the 1950s and 1960s, he flirted with the avant-garde emanating from the Continent. This included the use of microtones and aleatoric (chance) procedures.

Overall, Iain Hamilton’s opus sits in four stylistic trajectories: Romanticism, Serialism, Avant-Garde, and Light. These streams are not always mutually exclusive or chronological. They often tend to blur around the edges.

One of Hamilton’s earliest successes was the Clarinet Concerto premiered in 1952. It was awarded a prize by the Royal Philharmonic Society. The three movements balance virtuosity, lyricism and intensity. Here and there jazz elements creep in: Gershwin is often hinted at. Success was guaranteed when Hamilton won the Koussevitzky Foundation Award for his Symphony No.2 (premiered 1953) which is powerfully constructed, well-scored and exploring many different moods.

In 1956, Hamilton wrote what would become his most “popular” work: the Scottish Dances. Despite having several nods towards Scottish music, the jazzy, smoochy mood typically suggests a night club in downtown New York, rather than a ceilidh in Nairn. Yet it is a fantastic piece that ought to be in every Scottish orchestra’s repertoire. Another early work that gained considerable celebrity was his 1912: A Light Overture (1958), based on music hall songs.

The essentially 12-tone choral work The Bermudas (1957), based on a text by Andrew Marvell and others, is satisfying and effective. It sat on the cusp of Hamilton’s stylistic metamorphosis between romanticism, serialism and more accessible music.

The Concerto for Jazz Trumpet, dating from 1958 was written for that year’s BBC Light Music Festival. It oozes jazz and big band and “was surprisingly worlds away from the austere modernism we generally associate with his music.” Kenneth Walton (The Scotsman 27 June 2011).

Iain Hamilton’s first Proms commission was the Cantos for horn, tuba, harp and orchestra (1965): it was judged to be demanding for both performers and audience. In 1973, he completed his operatic masterpiece, The Cataline Conspiracy. Audiences were impressed, but a little bemused by the stark musical language. This opera was supposedly a commentary on Edward Heath’s government, a fact that would mean any future performances would need some contextualisation to the events of nearly half a century ago. The tonal Anna Karenina was premiered by the English National Opera in 1978. Several other operas still await a first performance.

As noted above, precious little of Iain Hamilton’s oeuvre has been commercially recorded. It makes it difficult to explore his music. To be sure, there have been several LPs and CDs dedicated to this repertoire over the past 60 years. The earliest LP (Lyrita RCS 5) was issued in 1960, featuring the Piano Sonata (1951) played by Margaret Kitchen. Much more recently, the early Clarinet and Trumpet Concertos have been issued on CD. Lyrita released The Bermudas on disc in 2018: it also included the Piano Concerto No.1 (1959/60, rev. 1967) and the Prom commission Cantos. It remains the only CD dedicated totally to Hamilton currently in the catalogue. The smoky Scottish Dances are available in at least four different recordings.

Enthusiasts must be prepared to explore second hand record shops for vinyl, and the internet for streaming services, YouTube and file sharing platforms to access more of his music.

If only one work can be heard…
This must be the Sinfonia for two orchestras which bamboozled the great and good at the Edinburgh Festival in 1959. It was commissioned by the Burns Federation to commemorate the poet’s bicentenary. The audience at the premiere were expecting something like Hamilton’s popular Scottish Dances. Or at the very least, a ‘Rhapsody’ of Scottish tunes. What they heard was an uncompromising serial work which was deemed to be tough and acerbic. Most of the audience were shocked, and made their feelings known to the composer and to the conductor Alexander Gibson. The president of the Burns Federation declared that it was “ghastly and tuneless.” Sixty-three years on, many listeners will still find the Sinfonia unmusical and “challenging.” Yet, what Hamiton did was to use the then-contemporary techniques prevalent in the United Kingdom, Europe and America, to create what some would regard as a masterwork. What he did not do, is take his admiration for Robert Burns and wrap it up in Tartan.

The Sinfonia for two orchestras can be heard on EMI Classics Label (5 86189 2). It is coupled with Hamilton’s deeply moving Violin Concerto and Alexander Goehr’s Violin Concerto, op.13. The soloist is Manoug Parikian. Alexander Gibson conducts the [Royal] Scottish National Orchestra (Hamilton) and Norman Del Mar and the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra (Goehr).

To be continued…

This essay was first printed in the 2024 edition of Spirited, the Journal of the English Music Festival.


 

Friday, 13 November 2026

Discovering Iain Hamilton (1922-2000) Part I

In the years following the end of the Second World War, four composers stood out as being set to dominate the British music scene. These were Elisabeth Lutyens, Peter Racine Fricker, Humphrey Searle and Iain Hamilton. History reveals that these prognostications were wrong. Apart from a few resolute followers, this group is now largely overlooked. Despite being much programmed in the 1950s, they gradually lost any public following. Fricker’s and Hamilton’s sojourn in the United States did little to promote their music “back home.” From the 1970s onwards there was a considerable resurgence of more ‘conservative’ composers, at least on record and CD, if not in the concert hall. This was at the expense of the above-named musicians. For many listeners, the post-war generation was dominated by Benjamin Britten and to a slightly lesser extent, Michael Tippett. And then there was Minimalism and Ambient… 

Brief Biography
Scotsman Iain Ellis Hamilton was born at 22 Woodburn Road, Newlands, Glasgow on 6 June 1922. Seven years later, the family moved down to London. Hamilton was originally destined to be an engineer. After education at Mill Hill School, he was apprenticed to the aircraft manufacturer, Handley Page. He was employed there during the war years. At this time, music was a private passion, studied in his spare time.

After the end of the Second World War, he won a scholarship to the Royal College of Music. His teachers there included William Alwyn for composition, and Harold Craxton for piano. Further study resulted in his BMus from London University. Music now dominated his life. He also worked in the teaching profession and for several musical organisations.

Iain Hamilton’s first major success was the Variations on an Original Theme for string orchestra, first heard in 1948. This was followed soon after by the Symphony No.1 (1952). Between 1952 and 1958 he was a lecturer at both Morley College, London and between 1956 and 1960 at London University. He found that he was now generally forgotten as a composer. In the intervening years, a younger generation, inspired by the sounds coming out of Darmstadt, Cologne and Paris, had usurped his position as a modernist. He attempted to remedy this by studying Anton Webern and aligning himself to the avant-garde movement.

Hamilton was aware of his social responsibilities in his chosen profession. For example, he was chairman of the Composers' Guild in 1958, and of the music section of the Institute of Contemporary Arts (1958-60). Despite later neglect by the BBC, he was on their Music Advisory Panel, as well as being involved in the Society for the Promotion of New Music.

Controversy surrounded Hamilton with his Sinfonia for two orchestras which was premiered at the Edinburgh Festival in 1959. See below for more details.

In 1961, Iain Hamilton moved to New York. He had secured appointments of Professor of Music at Duke University, North Carolina, and at the City University of New York. The following year he was Resident Composer at Tanglewood in the Berkshire Hills, Massachusetts. Two major works date from the American years: the operas Agamemnon (libretto by Hamilton) and the Royal Hunt of the Sun, based on Peter Schaffer’s eponymous play. In 1974, Hamilton had a major success with his opera, The Cataline Conspiracy. Premiered in Stirling, this had a run of ten performances in Glasgow.

Iain Hamilton returned to London in 1981. From this time, his style became “increasingly euphonious and romantic in character, inhabiting an altogether more ingratiating sound-world than earlier in his career.” (Hugh Wood, The Guardian, 3 August 2000). A successful Symphony No.4 was premiered in Edinburgh during January 1983. The Piano Concerto No.2 (premiered, 1989) was an interesting return to his more abrasive style. Sadly, Hamilton was increasingly ignored by concert promoters and broadcasters. Many of his later scores remain unperformed and unpublished. His seventieth birthday was marked by a “token” celebration: there was a performance of his Commedia: Concerto for orchestra (1972) during the 1992 Prom Season.

Hamilton’s final compositions were The Wild Garden for clarinet and piano and London: A Kaleidoscope for Piano and Orchestra.

Iain Hamilton died in Cromwell Hospital, London on 21 July 2000. He was aged 78 years.

To be continued…

Thanks to the Scottish Music Centre for permission to use the photograph of Iain Hamilton.

This essay was first printed in the 2024 edition of Spirited, the Journal of the English Music Festival.

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

British Concertante miniatures with character and poise.

This collection of crossover music - poised between light and art - opens with four pieces by Angela Morley, an English composer, arranger, and conductor whose career bridged British light music and Hollywood film scoring. Born Wally Stott, she came to public notice through her stylish arrangements for radio and television, especially The Goon Show. After transitioning in 1972, she built a second career in Los Angeles, orchestrating for major composers and contributing to scores for Star Wars, E.T., Superman, and Home Alone.

The first, The Liaison for violin, cello and orchestra, is a heartfelt discussion between the two protagonists. Whether the conversation is philosophical, nostalgic, or romantic, Morley creates a charming sound world in such a short piece. This is followed by another reflective number, Reverie scored for solo violin and orchestra. It has a lovely, gentle melody which permeates the piece. Once again, it is too short, the listener is just getting into the ambience when it ceases. A Tender Mood is exactly what it says on the tin: the solo violinist captures the atmosphere well, with this wistful song. Angela Morley’s final contribution is Harlequin. He is the spry trickster of commedia dell’arte, and is defined by his acrobatics, quick wit, and diamond‑patterned costume. A mischievous servant, he schemes, flirts, and outsmarts rivals with playful ingenuity. The music, written for clarinet and orchestra captures this roguish vivacity.

The liner notes explain that Bryan Kelly’s Concerto for Two Trumpets was written in Italy and originally had an organ accompaniment. He later decided to arrange it with strings. The Concerto opens with a good-humoured, rhythmic Allegro, that is followed by a plaintive Andante, whose sadness feels entirely unforced. It concludes with a rip-roaring Allegro designed to show off the trumpeters’ virtuosity, full of sparkle and energetic interplay. It is a definite candidate for a Promenade Concert.

Sadly, most listeners will associate Francis Chagrin only with the 1955 film The Colditz Story. There was much more to this Continental Briton than that. Born in Bucharest as Alexander Paucker he settled in the United Kingdom in 1936. He composed over two hundred scores for films, as well as writing music for theatre and radio. There are also some outstanding concert hall works including two Symphonies and a Piano Concerto. The Sarabande is a short piece for oboe, or flute, or violin and orchestra; it is heard here played on the oboe. This slow, stately dance is shaped with a calm dignity and a lightly solemn air.

The impetus for Philip Spratley’s Belvoir Suite for flute and orchestra was the view from his studio back in the 1970s. He looked out onto the rolling pastoral Vale of Belvoir and the commanding, hill-crowned Castle. The Suite opens with an urbane neo-Baroque evocation of the Castle, but subject to a few modern twists and turns. The second movement is the Elegy for Isobel in memory of a young chorister, presumably from Bourne Abbey where he was director of music. It is suitably lugubrious, but never maudlin. The third movement celebrates happier things with a wistful portrayal of The Girls with the long hair. The Suite concludes with a clip‑cloppy, happy‑go‑lucky depiction of Trudy exercising her horse in the Vale on an early morning. This is a magical suite, full of interest and alive with character and quiet enchantment. The flute playing is a delight.

Bryan Kelly’s music is marked by a lightly neo‑classical English/French blend of influences shaped by his studies with Herbert Howells and Nadia Boulanger. His Globe Theatre Suite, for recorder and orchestra, neatly balances echoes of the 1599 building with a touch of tongue‑in‑cheek wit, more at home in the 1997 reconstruction. The eight short movements are consistently entertaining, with excellent recorder playing from John Turner. Think Peter Warlock’s Capriol Suite or Poulenc’s Suite française (d’après Claude Gervaise) for an intimation of style.

English composer David Lyon (born in Walsall in 1938) has written across a wide range of genres, from orchestral and chamber works to theatre pieces, typically in an accessible idiom with a strong emphasis on melody, rhythm, and colour. The Piano Concerto in One Movement was completed when Lyon was still a student at the Royal College of Music but remained unperformed. In 2015, he revisited it, making changes to the orchestration, while leaving the formal structure largely intact. It is conceived in sonata form, with a cadenza at the end of the development section. This concerto struck me more by its rhythmic vitality and the luminous orchestration than its melodic invention. Overall, it is impressive and deserves to be heard, successfully bridging the line between light and concert music.

The liner notes are right to say that Maurice Ravel’s Pavane pour une infante défunte has been arranged for almost every conceivable combination of instruments. My favourites remain the original piano version dating from 1899 and Ravel’s own orchestration made in 1910. Least appealing is the arrangement for five accordions. Even so, I was pleasantly surprised by John Fox’s delicious reworking for soprano saxophone and orchestra. Although Ravel insisted that the piece carried no programme or dedication, this arrangement preserves its mood of nostalgia and elegance, but never quite crosses into mourning.

Great recording, splendid performances from all concerned and helpful liner notes makes this a rewarding disc.

The disc offers concertante miniatures with character and poise, delivered with a level of polish and skill that makes the programme both engaging and distinctive. More please!

Track Listing:
Angela Morley (1924-2009)

The Liaison (2004)
Robert Gibbs (violin), James Potter (cello)
Reverie (2004)
A Tender Mood (2004)
Geoffrey Allan (violin)
Harlequin (2004)
Verity Butler (clarinet)
Royal Ballet Sinfonia/Barry Wordsworth
Bryan Kelly (b.1934)
Concerto for two trumpets (1982)
Michael Allen, Tim Hawes (trumpets), Royal Ballet Sinfonia/Barry Wordsworth
Francis Chagrin (1905-72)
Sarabande (1952)
Alaster Bentley (oboe), Royal Ballet Sinfonia/Barry Wordsworth
Philip Spratley (b.1942)
Belvoir Suite (1977)
Carla Rees (flute), Royal Ballet Sinfonia/Barry Wordsworth
Bryan Kelly
Globe Theatre Suite (2005)
John Turner (recorder), Royal Ballet Sinfonia/Barry Wordsworth
David Lyon (b.1938)
Piano Concerto in One Movement (2015)
Alasdair Hogarth (piano), RTE Concert Orchestra/Gavin Sutherland
Maurice Ravel (1875-1937) arr. John Fox (1926-2015)
Pavane for a dead infanta
Lara Jones (soprano saxophone), Sinfonia Viva/Nicholas Kok
rec. 1997-2016 at various venues: Angel Studios London, Derby Assembly Rooms, RTE Radio Centre, Dublin.
Heritage HTGCD 191
With thanks to MusicWeb International where this review was first published.

Saturday, 7 November 2026

A classic train thriller that never quite arrives - saved by Benjamin Frankel’s stylish score.

The other night I watched Sleeping Car to Trieste, (1948) a so-called comedy thriller. Espionage thrillers set on continental trains have long been a reliable cinematic device, thins of Night Train to Munich, The Lady Vanishes and Murder on the Orient Express.

The story turns on the theft of a Paris diplomat’s diary containing politically sensitive information; the thief is swiftly double‑crossed, and both men head for the Trieste express, where - conveniently for the narrative - a police chief is among the passengers. More would give the game away…

One contemporary reviewer considered that although the opening promises momentum, the film spends an inordinate amount of time sketching its mixed assortment of passengers, and the action stalls until well past the halfway mark. I enjoyed the interaction of the passengers.

Jean Kent and Albert Lieven make competent villains, Alan Wheatley neatly suggests the treacherous accomplice, with Finlay Currie and Paul Dupuis all adding interest. A highlight for me was David Tomlinson portraying the typical Englishman abroad. Bonar Colleano playing an American soldier on furlough provides a breath of fresh air.

Benjamin Frankel (1906–73) was a London‑born composer who moved fluently between jazz, film, and the concert hall. His more than a hundred feature and documentary film and scores show a sharp ear for character, while his later concert works - eight symphonies, five quartets, and the Holocaust‑memorial Violin Concerto - pursue a cool, disciplined tonal‑serial idiom that remains distinctive.

Frankel’s score for Sleeping Car to Trieste is a compact, stylish fragment of late‑1940s British film music: taut, economical, and quietly sophisticated. Only two cues have survived on record, although the entire film is available on YouTube. “Sleeping Car Train” and “Waltz,” both recorded by the London Symphony Orchestra under Muir Mathieson show Frankel’s early studio craft at its most disciplined.

The train cue is brisk, rhythmically alert, and lightly suspenseful, built from crisp orchestral gestures that propel the narrative without drawing attention to themselves. The Waltz, a brief and faintly ironic salon piece, is elegant and cool, harmonically lean, its transparency suggesting social poise stretched over underlying tension. It is very much in keeping with the film’s espionage atmosphere.

Within Frankel’s broader output, these miniatures sit squarely in his 1940s idiom: concise dramatic writing with a slightly noirish harmonic edge, professional and unsentimental. They are modest but classy demonstrations of his ability to create atmosphere with minimal means-the train cue’s clipped propulsion suiting the thriller setting, the waltz showing his knack for understated character music. Not essential Frankel, but a neat illustration of British studio discipline at its most controlled.

Listen to the Opening Credits, here, and the Waltz, here, from Sleeping Car to Trieste played by the London Symphony Orchestra conducted by Muir Mathieson. Both cues also appear on the British Film Music Vol. 3 compilation (Pearl GEM 0141).

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Mentor and Muse: Songs by Vaughan Williams and the women around him.

It is worth stating from the outset that Kitty Whately has a genuinely compelling voice. Her rich, warm mezzo-soprano, combined with her dramatic focus and well‑shaped phrasing, gives her singing a distinctive character. Naturally, William Vann brings his huge talent to bear on each song, providing her with finely judged support throughout.

This new Albion recording reflects several years of collaboration between these two musicians, during which they became increasingly drawn to Vaughan Williams’s wider musical circle, particularly the women composers and poets who shaped his milieu. The album acknowledges RVW’s role as a mentor to Grace Williams and Elizabeth Maconchy, while also highlighting the poetry of his wife Ursula Vaughan Williams and relation Fredegond Shove, revealing a network of creative relationships that inform the programme and clearly engage the performers.

The recital opens with an “old favourite” – The Sky above the Roof. It was composed for Mabel Dearmer in 1908 and sets her translation of Verlaine’s Le ciel est pardessus le toit. RVW initially resisted the project but finally relented. The story goes that one day he went up to his study, saw the mess it was in, and wrote the song rather than tidy up. The poem contrasts a serene, sun‑drenched rooftop world with a quieter undercurrent of reflection and regret. Critics often note the technical refinement Vaughan Williams gained from his studies with Maurice Ravel in Paris: it is clearly reflected in this expressive setting.

Simon Heffer’s remark in his 2000 study of the composer describes “…Fredegond Shove, [as] a wholly un-exceptional poet…”  This is a good example of how certain kinds of literary achievement have been undervalued. Her gifts are quiet, and that quietness has often been mistaken for shallowness. Her poems belong to a small, modest strand of early twentieth‑century English verse - spiritual, diffident in style, and limited in scope. It is a mix that seldom draws much notice.

Fredegond Maitland (later Shove) was the daughter of Adeline’s elder sister, Florence. She and her sister Ermengard served as bridesmaids at their aunt’s wedding to Vaughan Williams in 1897. In the years before the First World War, Fredegond spent periods living with Ralph and Adeline in London while studying at Newnham College, Cambridge, a proximity that informed her early intellectual and poetic development.

A.E.F Dickinson has noted that the Four Poems of Fredegond Shove (1925) brings together four settings of poems from her published collection Dreams and Journeys (1918). There is no attempt by RVW to create a song cycle.

Motion and Stillness is not as well-known as the last two songs in the group, but its intensity is unmistakable. It ponders the enduring land and sea set against vanishing clouds and ships - a world caught between calm stability and fading hope. It is a fine fusion of words and music.

Four Nights traces the speaker’s thoughts across the four seasons, moving from spring’s heavenly visions to summer’s unrest, autumn’s fierce turbulence, and finally winter’s deep, angel‑guarded stillness where the soul lies in an enchanted quiet. RVW uses a variety of modal scales and a complex accompaniment that never lacks interest.

The most spartan of this group is The New Ghost where the progress of the song “alternates between recitative and chant espressif.” The mystical poem depicts a soul leaving its body and meeting Christ in a bright, spring‑like vision; their silent embrace marks the ghost’s peace as he follows the Lord into the heavenly realm.

The Water Mill is the best known of these four songs. Shove’s poem offers a kindly, detailed portrait of an old mill and the family who run it, evoking the steady rhythms and quiet human dramas of rural life where toil, nature, and domestic routine flow together in a single unhurried day. Vaughan Williams has provided an onomatopoeic, Schubertian vocal line and accompaniment echoing the mill lade. One critic has suggested that "though only an English poet would so carefully note that the Miller's tabby was 'as lean as a healthy cat can be.'"

Like many listeners of a certain age, I first encountered Elizabeth Maconchy’s music through her remarkable portrait of a river, the overture Proud Thames, issued on Lyrita Records (SRCS 57). Since then, a number of her compositions have been recorded, though much still awaits exploration by performers and record companies. Even so, the existing catalogue is substantial enough to allow an educated assessment of her achievement.

In recent years, two discs of songs by Maconchy and her mentor and teacher RVW have appeared on Resonaus Classics: reviewed here, and here. Inevitably, there is some overlap between the track listings compiled by James Geer (tenor) and Ronald Woodley (piano) and the seven songs recorded on this new album.

The first song is In a Fountain Court (1929) by the Symbolist poet Arthur Symons. This poem evokes a languid June afternoon where nature’s drowsy peace becomes a setting of expectancy, the speaker waiting for the beloved to arrive. Maconchy has not eschewed modal scales and harmonies in this gentle song.

Impetuous Heart, Be Still (1924) is the earliest Maconchy piece on this disc. It sets a star‑lit yearning verse by W.B. Yeats from his play The Countess Kathleen. An impressively confident piece for a composer still in her teens.

The intensely beautiful The Woodspurge was penned in 1930. The liner notes explain that it was originally a piano solo, written the previous year. Rossetti’s poem captures a moment of weariness in which grief reduces everything to one simple, almost accidental observation: the woodspurge’s three‑cupped flower, the single fact that remains when all else is drained away.

The Exequy (1956) sets a handful of lines from Henry King’s long elegy Exequy on His Wife, written as the Bishop of Chichester mourned his young spouse. It is not easy to absorb: the musical realisation is often astringent, though at moments unexpectedly exquisite. Its tolling accompaniment offers a discreet nod to Ravel’s Le Gibet from Gaspard de la Nuit.

Two songs follow, taken from Four Shakespeare Songs. Nos. 1, 2 and 4 date from 1965, while No. 3 was completed earlier, in 1956. The first, Come Away, Death (from Twelfth Night, Act II, Scene 4), is intense and marked by rapid shifts of dynamic. The final song, King Stephen (from Othello, Act II, Scene 3) is a will‑o’-the‑wisp miniature, its toccata‑like accompaniment sharpening the Bard’s wry admonition against pride.

The last of Elizabeth Maconchy’s songs recorded here is Ophelia’s Song (from Hamlet Act IV Scene 5) (1926). This is a delicate lament in which a grief‑stricken young woman describes her true love’s death with childlike simplicity and haunting tenderness.

Grace Williams is one of the quadrumvirate of composers who dominated Welsh music in the twentieth century. The other three were Alun Hoddinott, William Mathias, and Daniel Jones. Williams was born in the coastal town of Barry in South Wales. She studied at the Royal College of Music under the auspices of ‘Uncle Ralph.’ Contemporaries included Imogen Holst and Elizabeth Maconchy.

The song cycle for contralto and piano, Billows of the Sea, was commissioned by the Guild for Promotion of Welsh Music for the 1969 Swansea Festival. The English texts chosen centred around themes of the ocean, seafaring, and parting.

The booklet quotes Kenneth Loveland, for The Times, who recalled that Grace Williams lived by the sea and “that her sea on this occasion is a demanding and angry one, tearing lovers apart…or claiming them as its prey…”

The opening song, to a text by Walter Scott, recounts how the noble Rosabelle, ignoring ominous warnings and portents, crosses the stormy Firth of Forth to visit her mother. She perishes at sea as supernatural fires blaze over Roslin Chapel in a prophetic tribute to her doomed lineage. It is a dramatic, non-strophic song that is operatic in scope. Tennyson’s Sweet and Low was originally part of Williams’s three Songs of Sleep, dating from 1959. It is an intense lullaby where the poet is expressing a mother’s hope that the West Wind will bring the child’s absent father safely home, as she lulls her baby to sleep. The anonymous Galloway ballad The Lowlands of Holland nearest approaches folk song, with a strophic form. Here, a young woman mourns the loss of her drowned lover, refusing all comfort or future suitors. The music well reflects the tragedy. Black-Eyed Susan is the most approachable stylistically, yet there is suppressed tragedy throughout. In this “scena” a young woman finds her sailor lover aboard the fleet, and the pair exchange vows of fidelity before duty forces “Sweet William” to depart and Susan to watch his ship sail away. Almost certainly they never saw each other again. A scene repeated so often in history.

One other number by Grace Williams is included. The gloomy, but perfectly judged setting of the anonymous ballad collected by Walter Scott, The Lament of the Border Widow (1952). Here a woman laments the murder of her beloved knight, burying him with her own hands and vowing never to love again.

For me, the highlight on this disc is Kitty Whately’s response to RVW’s Four Last Songs (1954-58). According to Michael Kennedy's Catalogue of Works, this was not his last work. It seems that The First Nowell was to follow. To be sure these were devised over a four-year period, with the last being completed shortly before the composer’s death on 26 August 1958. They are all settings of poems by his wife Ursula. I think that the listener will be struck by the valedictory mood of these songs, as if both partners knew that time together was short and precious.

The first song shows Procris in her last moments after being struck by an arrow from her husband, Cephalus. Around her, spring is beginning to wake, and its gentle new life makes her fading hope and stillness feel even more tragic. The second, Tired, creates a quiet, tender closeness in which sleep becomes a refuge, its soft firelit imagery suggesting love expressed through stillness and memory rather than passion. Hands, Eyes and Hearts distils love into touch, vision, and inner stillness, each offering a wordless pledge. The final number requires the listener to recall that Menelaus, King of Sparta, had his wife Helen taken by Paris to his native Troy. It is all in the Iliad. This is the most dramatic song of the set. Menelaus comes home not to remembered earthly beauty but to a dwelling of timeless welcome, where wind, sea and lamplight settle into a quiet vision of rest and renewal.

I have mentioned the stunning performances at the beginning of this review. This is complemented with an excellent recording, most helpful programme notes and complete texts for all the songs. For details of Kitty Whately’s and William Vann’s resumes see their respective webpages.

In sum, this Albion release offers a vividly drawn portrait of Vaughan Williams’s creative circle, with the performers bringing great sensitivity to the songs of Grace Williams, Elizabeth Maconchy and RVW himself.

Track Listing:
Ralph Vaughan Williams (1872-1958)

The Sky Above the Roof (Mabel Dearmer) (1908)
Four poems by Fredegond Shove (1925): Motion and Stillness; Four Nights; The New Ghost; The Water Mill.
Elizabeth Maconchy (1907-1994)
In Fountain Court (Arthur Symons) (1929); Impetuous Heart, Be Still (W.B. Yeats) (1924); The Woodspurge (Dante Gabriel Rossetti) (1930); The Exequy (Henry King) (1956); Come Away, Death (William Shakespeare) (1965); King Stephen (William Shakespeare) (1965); Ophelia’s Song (William Shakespeare) (1926)
Grace Williams (1906-1977)
Billows of the Sea (1969): Rosabelle (Walter Scott); Sweet and Low (Alfred, Lord Tennyson); The Lowlands of Holland (Trad.); Black-Eyed Susan (John Gay)
The Lament of the Border Widow (Anon. collected Walter Scott) (1952)
Ralph Vaughan Williams
Four Last Songs (Ursula Vaughan Williams) (1954-58): Procris; Tired; Hands, Eyes and Hearts; Menelaus.
Kitty Whately (mezzo-soprano); William Vann (piano)
rec. July and October 2025 St. George’s Headstone, London.
Albion Records ALBCD 069


Sunday, 1 November 2026

Ralph Vaughan Williams: Six Studies in English Folk Song (1926)

The Six Studies in English Folk Song were written a century ago in 1926. The previous year, Ralph Vaughan Williams had completed a number of important works including the enigmatic Suite for solo viola, small wordless chorus, and small orchestra Flos Campi, the oratorio Sancta Civitas and the Concerto in D minor (Concerto Accademico) for violin and orchestra. He had also made a major contribution to the hymnbook Songs of Praise with many new and edited tunes. The present year was less hectic, with only one other piece listed in the catalogue: the masque On Christmas Night.

Vaughan Williams had long been a collector of folk song and had used the results in a number of works, either literally or by allusion. Important compositions inspired by these folk songs included the three (the third was discarded) Norfolk Rhapsodies (1906), the ballad-opera Hugh the Drover (1924) and Fantasia on Greensleeves (1934) as well as many arrangements for choir and solo singers.

Six Studies in English Folk Song, although not being exact transcriptions of any song have been identified with particular tunes. (Kennedy, Michael, A Catalogue of the Works of Ralph Vaughan Williams (Oxford, OUP, 1996))

1.      Adagio (Lovely on the Water: The Springtime of the Year)

2.      Andante sostenuto (Spurn Point)

3.      Larghetto (Van Dieman's Land)

4.      Lento (She Borrowed Some of her Mother's Gold)

5.      Andante tranquillo (The Lady and the Dragoon)

6.      Allegro vivace (As I walked over London Bridge)

All the tunes were collected ‘in the field’ by the composer. Each is presented in a relatively simple manner and is then freely treated and ornamented by the soloists. The mood of the complete set is reflective with only the concluding allegro vivace being more outgoing. The impact of these studies is heightened by their conciseness and brevity.

The Six Studies were dedicated to the cellist May Mukle (1880-1963) who gave the first performance at the Scala Theatre, London on 4 June 1926 during the English Folk Dance Society Festival. She was accompanied on the piano by her sister, Anne.

There are a number of versions of the Six Studies in the R.V.W. catalogue including for solo violin, viola and clarinet. In 1957 Arnold Foster (1896/8-1963) made an attractive arrangement for cello and small orchestra.

Listen to Vaughan Williams’s Six Studies in English Folk Song on YouTube, here. The performers are Denise Djokic (cello), David Jalbert (piano).

With thanks to the English Music Festival where this was first published.