Possible Works to Revive?
Conclusion
Concluded
This essay was first printed in the 2024 edition of Spirited, the Journal of the English Music Festival.
‘Smart, well-written and knowledgeable’ – Saga Magazine
Iain Hamilton’s catalogue is wide ranging, and includes operas, four symphonies, numerous concertos, orchestral works, chamber, piano and organ music. Stylistically, his exemplars were Bartók, Stravinsky, Schoenberg and later Anton Webern. Yet, Hamilton evolved his own style, synthesising serialism, non-tonal structures and various degrees of dissonance. In the 1950s and 1960s, he flirted with the avant-garde emanating from the Continent. This included the use of microtones and aleatoric (chance) procedures.
Overall, Iain Hamilton’s opus
sits in four stylistic trajectories: Romanticism, Serialism, Avant-Garde, and
Light. These streams are not always mutually exclusive or chronological. They
often tend to blur around the edges.
One of Hamilton’s earliest successes was the Clarinet Concerto premiered in 1952. It was awarded a prize by the Royal Philharmonic Society. The three movements balance virtuosity, lyricism and intensity. Here and there jazz elements creep in: Gershwin is often hinted at. Success was guaranteed when Hamilton won the Koussevitzky Foundation Award for his Symphony No.2 (premiered 1953) which is powerfully constructed, well-scored and exploring many different moods.
In 1956, Hamilton wrote what
would become his most “popular” work: the Scottish Dances. Despite
having several nods towards Scottish music, the jazzy, smoochy mood typically
suggests a night club in downtown New York, rather than a ceilidh in Nairn. Yet
it is a fantastic piece that ought to be in every Scottish orchestra’s
repertoire. Another early work that gained considerable celebrity was his 1912:
A Light Overture (1958), based on music hall songs.
The essentially 12-tone choral work The Bermudas (1957), based on a text by Andrew Marvell and others, is satisfying and effective. It sat on the cusp of Hamilton’s stylistic metamorphosis between romanticism, serialism and more accessible music.
The Concerto for Jazz Trumpet,
dating from 1958 was written for that year’s BBC Light Music Festival. It oozes
jazz and big band and “was surprisingly worlds away from the austere modernism
we generally associate with his music.” Kenneth Walton (The Scotsman 27
June 2011).
Iain Hamilton’s first Proms commission was the Cantos for horn, tuba, harp and orchestra (1965): it was judged to be demanding for both performers and audience. In 1973, he completed his operatic masterpiece, The Cataline Conspiracy. Audiences were impressed, but a little bemused by the stark musical language. This opera was supposedly a commentary on Edward Heath’s government, a fact that would mean any future performances would need some contextualisation to the events of nearly half a century ago. The tonal Anna Karenina was premiered by the English National Opera in 1978. Several other operas still await a first performance.
As noted above, precious little of Iain Hamilton’s oeuvre has been commercially recorded. It makes it difficult to explore his music. To be sure, there have been several LPs and CDs dedicated to this repertoire over the past 60 years. The earliest LP (Lyrita RCS 5) was issued in 1960, featuring the Piano Sonata (1951) played by Margaret Kitchen. Much more recently, the early Clarinet and Trumpet Concertos have been issued on CD. Lyrita released The Bermudas on disc in 2018: it also included the Piano Concerto No.1 (1959/60, rev. 1967) and the Prom commission Cantos. It remains the only CD dedicated totally to Hamilton currently in the catalogue. The smoky Scottish Dances are available in at least four different recordings.
Enthusiasts must be prepared to
explore second hand record shops for vinyl, and the internet for streaming
services, YouTube and file sharing platforms to access more of his music.
To be
continued…
This essay was first printed in the 2024 edition of Spirited, the Journal of the English Music Festival.
Iain Hamilton’s first major success was the Variations on an Original Theme for string orchestra, first heard in 1948. This was followed soon after by the Symphony No.1 (1952). Between 1952 and 1958 he was a lecturer at both Morley College, London and between 1956 and 1960 at London University. He found that he was now generally forgotten as a composer. In the intervening years, a younger generation, inspired by the sounds coming out of Darmstadt, Cologne and Paris, had usurped his position as a modernist. He attempted to remedy this by studying Anton Webern and aligning himself to the avant-garde movement.
Hamilton was aware of his social
responsibilities in his chosen profession. For example, he was chairman of the
Composers' Guild in 1958, and of the music section of the Institute of
Contemporary Arts (1958-60). Despite later neglect by the BBC, he was on their Music
Advisory Panel, as well as being involved in the Society for the Promotion of
New Music.
Controversy surrounded Hamilton
with his Sinfonia for two orchestras which was premiered at the Edinburgh
Festival in 1959. See below for more details.
In 1961, Iain Hamilton moved to
New York. He had secured appointments of Professor of Music at Duke University,
North Carolina, and at the City University of New York. The following year he
was Resident Composer at Tanglewood in the Berkshire Hills, Massachusetts. Two
major works date from the American years: the operas Agamemnon (libretto
by Hamilton) and the Royal Hunt of the Sun, based on Peter Schaffer’s eponymous
play. In 1974, Hamilton had a major success with his opera, The Cataline
Conspiracy. Premiered in Stirling, this had a run of ten performances in
Glasgow.
Iain Hamilton returned to London
in 1981. From this time, his style became “increasingly euphonious and
romantic in character, inhabiting an altogether more ingratiating sound-world
than earlier in his career.” (Hugh Wood, The Guardian, 3 August 2000). A
successful Symphony No.4 was premiered in Edinburgh during January 1983. The
Piano Concerto No.2 (premiered, 1989) was an interesting return to his more abrasive
style. Sadly, Hamilton was increasingly ignored by concert promoters and
broadcasters. Many of his later scores remain unperformed and unpublished. His
seventieth birthday was marked by a “token” celebration: there was a
performance of his Commedia: Concerto for orchestra (1972) during the
1992 Prom Season.
Hamilton’s final compositions
were The Wild Garden for clarinet and piano and London: A
Kaleidoscope for Piano and Orchestra.
Iain Hamilton died in Cromwell
Hospital, London on 21 July 2000. He was aged 78 years.
To be continued…
Thanks to the Scottish Music Centre for permission to use the photograph of Iain Hamilton.
This essay was first printed in the 2024 edition of Spirited, the Journal of the English Music Festival.
The first, The Liaison for
violin, cello and orchestra, is a heartfelt discussion between the two
protagonists. Whether the conversation is philosophical, nostalgic, or
romantic, Morley creates a charming sound world in such a short piece. This is
followed by another reflective number, Reverie scored for solo violin
and orchestra. It has a lovely, gentle melody which permeates the piece. Once
again, it is too short, the listener is just getting into the ambience when it
ceases. A Tender Mood is exactly what it says on the tin: the solo
violinist captures the atmosphere well, with this wistful song. Angela Morley’s
final contribution is Harlequin. He is the spry trickster of commedia
dell’arte, and is defined by his acrobatics, quick wit, and diamond‑patterned
costume. A mischievous servant, he schemes, flirts, and outsmarts rivals with
playful ingenuity. The music, written for clarinet and orchestra captures this roguish
vivacity.
The liner notes explain that Bryan Kelly’s Concerto for Two Trumpets was written in Italy and originally had an organ accompaniment. He later decided to arrange it with strings. The Concerto opens with a good-humoured, rhythmic Allegro, that is followed by a plaintive Andante, whose sadness feels entirely unforced. It concludes with a rip-roaring Allegro designed to show off the trumpeters’ virtuosity, full of sparkle and energetic interplay. It is a definite candidate for a Promenade Concert.
Sadly, most listeners will associate Francis Chagrin only with the 1955 film The Colditz Story. There was much more to this Continental Briton than that. Born in Bucharest as Alexander Paucker he settled in the United Kingdom in 1936. He composed over two hundred scores for films, as well as writing music for theatre and radio. There are also some outstanding concert hall works including two Symphonies and a Piano Concerto. The Sarabande is a short piece for oboe, or flute, or violin and orchestra; it is heard here played on the oboe. This slow, stately dance is shaped with a calm dignity and a lightly solemn air.
The impetus for Philip Spratley’s Belvoir Suite for flute and orchestra was the view from his studio back in the 1970s. He looked out onto the rolling pastoral Vale of Belvoir and the commanding, hill-crowned Castle. The Suite opens with an urbane neo-Baroque evocation of the Castle, but subject to a few modern twists and turns. The second movement is the Elegy for Isobel in memory of a young chorister, presumably from Bourne Abbey where he was director of music. It is suitably lugubrious, but never maudlin. The third movement celebrates happier things with a wistful portrayal of The Girls with the long hair. The Suite concludes with a clip‑cloppy, happy‑go‑lucky depiction of Trudy exercising her horse in the Vale on an early morning. This is a magical suite, full of interest and alive with character and quiet enchantment. The flute playing is a delight.
Bryan Kelly’s music is marked by a lightly neo‑classical English/French blend of influences shaped by his studies with Herbert Howells and Nadia Boulanger. His Globe Theatre Suite, for recorder and orchestra, neatly balances echoes of the 1599 building with a touch of tongue‑in‑cheek wit, more at home in the 1997 reconstruction. The eight short movements are consistently entertaining, with excellent recorder playing from John Turner. Think Peter Warlock’s Capriol Suite or Poulenc’s Suite française (d’après Claude Gervaise) for an intimation of style.
English composer David Lyon (born in Walsall in 1938) has written across a wide range of genres, from orchestral and chamber works to theatre pieces, typically in an accessible idiom with a strong emphasis on melody, rhythm, and colour. The Piano Concerto in One Movement was completed when Lyon was still a student at the Royal College of Music but remained unperformed. In 2015, he revisited it, making changes to the orchestration, while leaving the formal structure largely intact. It is conceived in sonata form, with a cadenza at the end of the development section. This concerto struck me more by its rhythmic vitality and the luminous orchestration than its melodic invention. Overall, it is impressive and deserves to be heard, successfully bridging the line between light and concert music.
The liner notes are right to say that Maurice Ravel’s Pavane pour une infante défunte has been arranged for almost every conceivable combination of instruments. My favourites remain the original piano version dating from 1899 and Ravel’s own orchestration made in 1910. Least appealing is the arrangement for five accordions. Even so, I was pleasantly surprised by John Fox’s delicious reworking for soprano saxophone and orchestra. Although Ravel insisted that the piece carried no programme or dedication, this arrangement preserves its mood of nostalgia and elegance, but never quite crosses into mourning.
Great recording, splendid performances from all concerned and helpful liner notes makes this a rewarding disc.
The disc offers concertante miniatures with character and poise, delivered with a level of polish and skill that makes the programme both engaging and distinctive. More please!
Track Listing:The story turns on the theft of a Paris diplomat’s diary containing politically sensitive information; the thief is swiftly double‑crossed, and both men head for the Trieste express, where - conveniently for the narrative - a police chief is among the passengers. More would give the game away…
One contemporary reviewer considered that although the opening promises momentum, the film spends an inordinate amount of time sketching its mixed assortment of passengers, and the action stalls until well past the halfway mark. I enjoyed the interaction of the passengers.
Jean Kent and Albert Lieven make
competent villains, Alan Wheatley neatly suggests the treacherous accomplice, with
Finlay Currie and Paul Dupuis all adding interest. A highlight for me was David
Tomlinson portraying the typical Englishman abroad. Bonar Colleano playing an
American soldier on furlough provides a breath of fresh air.
Benjamin Frankel (1906–73) was a London‑born composer who moved fluently between jazz, film, and the concert hall. His more than a hundred feature and documentary film and scores show a sharp ear for character, while his later concert works - eight symphonies, five quartets, and the Holocaust‑memorial Violin Concerto - pursue a cool, disciplined tonal‑serial idiom that remains distinctive.
Frankel’s score for Sleeping Car to Trieste is a compact, stylish fragment of late‑1940s British film music: taut, economical, and quietly sophisticated. Only two cues have survived on record, although the entire film is available on YouTube. “Sleeping Car Train” and “Waltz,” both recorded by the London Symphony Orchestra under Muir Mathieson show Frankel’s early studio craft at its most disciplined.
The train cue is brisk,
rhythmically alert, and lightly suspenseful, built from crisp orchestral
gestures that propel the narrative without drawing attention to themselves. The
Waltz, a brief and faintly ironic salon piece, is elegant and cool,
harmonically lean, its transparency suggesting social poise stretched over
underlying tension. It is very much in keeping with the film’s espionage
atmosphere.
Within Frankel’s broader output, these miniatures sit squarely in his 1940s idiom: concise dramatic writing with a slightly noirish harmonic edge, professional and unsentimental. They are modest but classy demonstrations of his ability to create atmosphere with minimal means-the train cue’s clipped propulsion suiting the thriller setting, the waltz showing his knack for understated character music. Not essential Frankel, but a neat illustration of British studio discipline at its most controlled.
Listen to the Opening Credits, here, and the Waltz, here, from Sleeping Car to Trieste played by the London Symphony Orchestra conducted by Muir Mathieson. Both cues also appear on the British Film Music Vol. 3 compilation (Pearl GEM 0141).
This new Albion recording reflects several years of collaboration between these two musicians, during which they became increasingly drawn to Vaughan Williams’s wider musical circle, particularly the women composers and poets who shaped his milieu. The album acknowledges RVW’s role as a mentor to Grace Williams and Elizabeth Maconchy, while also highlighting the poetry of his wife Ursula Vaughan Williams and relation Fredegond Shove, revealing a network of creative relationships that inform the programme and clearly engage the performers.
The recital opens with an “old favourite” – The Sky above the Roof. It was composed for Mabel Dearmer in 1908 and sets her translation of Verlaine’s Le ciel est pardessus le toit. RVW initially resisted the project but finally relented. The story goes that one day he went up to his study, saw the mess it was in, and wrote the song rather than tidy up. The poem contrasts a serene, sun‑drenched rooftop world with a quieter undercurrent of reflection and regret. Critics often note the technical refinement Vaughan Williams gained from his studies with Maurice Ravel in Paris: it is clearly reflected in this expressive setting.
Simon Heffer’s remark in his 2000 study of the composer describes “…Fredegond Shove, [as] a wholly un-exceptional poet…” This is a good example of how certain kinds of literary achievement have been undervalued. Her gifts are quiet, and that quietness has often been mistaken for shallowness. Her poems belong to a small, modest strand of early twentieth‑century English verse - spiritual, diffident in style, and limited in scope. It is a mix that seldom draws much notice.
Fredegond Maitland (later Shove) was the daughter of Adeline’s elder sister, Florence. She and her sister Ermengard served as bridesmaids at their aunt’s wedding to Vaughan Williams in 1897. In the years before the First World War, Fredegond spent periods living with Ralph and Adeline in London while studying at Newnham College, Cambridge, a proximity that informed her early intellectual and poetic development.
A.E.F Dickinson has noted that the Four Poems of Fredegond Shove (1925) brings together four settings of poems from her published collection Dreams and Journeys (1918). There is no attempt by RVW to create a song cycle.
Motion and Stillness is not as well-known as the last two songs in the group, but its intensity is unmistakable. It ponders the enduring land and sea set against vanishing clouds and ships - a world caught between calm stability and fading hope. It is a fine fusion of words and music.
Four Nights traces the
speaker’s thoughts across the four seasons, moving from spring’s heavenly
visions to summer’s unrest, autumn’s fierce turbulence, and finally winter’s
deep, angel‑guarded stillness where the soul lies in an enchanted quiet. RVW
uses a variety of modal scales and a complex accompaniment that never lacks
interest.
The most spartan of this group is
The New Ghost where the progress of the song “alternates between
recitative and chant espressif.” The mystical poem depicts a soul
leaving its body and meeting Christ in a bright, spring‑like vision; their
silent embrace marks the ghost’s peace as he follows the Lord into the heavenly
realm.
The Water Mill is the best
known of these four songs. Shove’s poem offers a kindly, detailed portrait of
an old mill and the family who run it, evoking the steady rhythms and quiet
human dramas of rural life where toil, nature, and domestic routine flow
together in a single unhurried day. Vaughan Williams has provided an
onomatopoeic, Schubertian vocal line and accompaniment echoing the mill lade. One
critic has suggested that "though only an English poet would so carefully
note that the Miller's tabby was 'as lean as a healthy cat can be.'"
Like many listeners of a certain age, I first encountered Elizabeth Maconchy’s music through her remarkable portrait of a river, the overture Proud Thames, issued on Lyrita Records (SRCS 57). Since then, a number of her compositions have been recorded, though much still awaits exploration by performers and record companies. Even so, the existing catalogue is substantial enough to allow an educated assessment of her achievement.
In recent years, two discs of
songs by Maconchy and her mentor and teacher RVW have appeared on Resonaus
Classics: reviewed here,
and here.
Inevitably, there is some overlap between the track listings compiled by James
Geer (tenor) and Ronald Woodley (piano) and the seven songs recorded on this
new album.
The first song is In a Fountain Court (1929) by the Symbolist poet Arthur Symons. This poem evokes a languid June afternoon where nature’s drowsy peace becomes a setting of expectancy, the speaker waiting for the beloved to arrive. Maconchy has not eschewed modal scales and harmonies in this gentle song.
Impetuous Heart, Be Still
(1924) is the earliest Maconchy piece on this disc. It sets a star‑lit yearning
verse by W.B. Yeats from his play The Countess Kathleen. An
impressively confident piece for a composer still in her teens.
The intensely beautiful The
Woodspurge was penned in 1930. The liner notes explain that it was
originally a piano solo, written the previous year. Rossetti’s poem captures a
moment of weariness in which grief reduces everything to one simple, almost
accidental observation: the woodspurge’s three‑cupped flower, the single fact
that remains when all else is drained away.
The Exequy (1956) sets a
handful of lines from Henry King’s long elegy Exequy on His Wife,
written as the Bishop of Chichester mourned his young spouse. It is not easy to
absorb: the musical realisation is often astringent, though at moments
unexpectedly exquisite. Its tolling accompaniment offers a discreet nod to
Ravel’s Le Gibet from Gaspard de la Nuit.
Two songs follow, taken from Four Shakespeare Songs. Nos. 1, 2 and 4 date from 1965, while No. 3 was completed earlier, in 1956. The first, Come Away, Death (from Twelfth Night, Act II, Scene 4), is intense and marked by rapid shifts of dynamic. The final song, King Stephen (from Othello, Act II, Scene 3) is a will‑o’-the‑wisp miniature, its toccata‑like accompaniment sharpening the Bard’s wry admonition against pride.
The last of Elizabeth Maconchy’s songs recorded here is Ophelia’s Song (from Hamlet Act IV Scene 5) (1926). This is a delicate lament in which a grief‑stricken young woman describes her true love’s death with childlike simplicity and haunting tenderness.
Grace Williams is one of the quadrumvirate of composers who dominated Welsh music in the twentieth century. The other three were Alun Hoddinott, William Mathias, and Daniel Jones. Williams was born in the coastal town of Barry in South Wales. She studied at the Royal College of Music under the auspices of ‘Uncle Ralph.’ Contemporaries included Imogen Holst and Elizabeth Maconchy.
The song cycle for contralto and
piano, Billows of the Sea, was commissioned by the Guild for Promotion
of Welsh Music for the 1969 Swansea Festival. The English texts chosen centred
around themes of the ocean, seafaring, and parting.
The booklet quotes Kenneth
Loveland, for The Times, who recalled that Grace Williams lived by the
sea and “that her sea on this occasion is a demanding and angry one, tearing
lovers apart…or claiming them as its prey…”
The opening song, to a text by
Walter Scott, recounts how the noble Rosabelle, ignoring ominous
warnings and portents, crosses the stormy Firth of Forth to visit her mother.
She perishes at sea as supernatural fires blaze over Roslin Chapel in a
prophetic tribute to her doomed lineage. It is a dramatic, non-strophic song
that is operatic in scope. Tennyson’s Sweet and Low was originally part
of Williams’s three Songs of Sleep, dating from 1959. It is an intense lullaby
where the poet is expressing a mother’s hope that the West Wind will bring the
child’s absent father safely home, as she lulls her baby to sleep. The
anonymous Galloway ballad The Lowlands of Holland nearest approaches
folk song, with a strophic form. Here, a young woman mourns the loss of her
drowned lover, refusing all comfort or future suitors. The music well reflects
the tragedy. Black-Eyed Susan is the most approachable stylistically,
yet there is suppressed tragedy throughout. In this “scena” a young woman finds
her sailor lover aboard the fleet, and the pair exchange vows of fidelity
before duty forces “Sweet William” to depart and Susan to watch his ship sail
away. Almost certainly they never saw each other again. A scene repeated so
often in history.
One other number by Grace Williams is included. The gloomy, but perfectly judged setting of the anonymous ballad collected by Walter Scott, The Lament of the Border Widow (1952). Here a woman laments the murder of her beloved knight, burying him with her own hands and vowing never to love again.
For me, the highlight on this disc is Kitty Whately’s response to RVW’s Four Last Songs (1954-58). According to Michael Kennedy's Catalogue of Works, this was not his last work. It seems that The First Nowell was to follow. To be sure these were devised over a four-year period, with the last being completed shortly before the composer’s death on 26 August 1958. They are all settings of poems by his wife Ursula. I think that the listener will be struck by the valedictory mood of these songs, as if both partners knew that time together was short and precious.
The first song shows Procris in her last moments after being struck by an arrow from her husband, Cephalus. Around her, spring is beginning to wake, and its gentle new life makes her fading hope and stillness feel even more tragic. The second, Tired, creates a quiet, tender closeness in which sleep becomes a refuge, its soft firelit imagery suggesting love expressed through stillness and memory rather than passion. Hands, Eyes and Hearts distils love into touch, vision, and inner stillness, each offering a wordless pledge. The final number requires the listener to recall that Menelaus, King of Sparta, had his wife Helen taken by Paris to his native Troy. It is all in the Iliad. This is the most dramatic song of the set. Menelaus comes home not to remembered earthly beauty but to a dwelling of timeless welcome, where wind, sea and lamplight settle into a quiet vision of rest and renewal.
I have mentioned the stunning performances at the beginning of this review. This is complemented with an excellent recording, most helpful programme notes and complete texts for all the songs. For details of Kitty Whately’s and William Vann’s resumes see their respective webpages.
In sum, this Albion release offers a vividly drawn portrait of Vaughan Williams’s creative circle, with the performers bringing great sensitivity to the songs of Grace Williams, Elizabeth Maconchy and RVW himself.
Track Listing:Vaughan Williams had long been a collector of folk song
and had used the results in a number of works, either literally or by allusion.
Important compositions inspired by these folk songs included the three (the
third was discarded) Norfolk Rhapsodies (1906), the ballad-opera Hugh
the Drover (1924) and Fantasia on Greensleeves (1934) as well as
many arrangements for choir and solo singers.
Six Studies in English Folk Song, although not being exact transcriptions of any song have been identified with particular tunes. (Kennedy, Michael, A Catalogue of the Works of Ralph Vaughan Williams (Oxford, OUP, 1996))
1. Adagio
(Lovely on the Water: The Springtime of the Year)
2. Andante
sostenuto (Spurn Point)
3. Larghetto
(Van Dieman's Land)
4. Lento
(She Borrowed Some of her Mother's Gold)
5. Andante
tranquillo (The Lady and the Dragoon)
6.
Allegro
vivace (As I walked over London Bridge)
All
the tunes were collected ‘in the field’ by the composer. Each is presented in a
relatively simple manner and is then freely treated and ornamented by the
soloists. The mood of the complete set is reflective with only the concluding
allegro vivace being more outgoing. The impact of these studies is heightened
by their conciseness and brevity.
The Six Studies were dedicated to the cellist May Mukle (1880-1963) who gave the first performance at the Scala Theatre, London on 4 June 1926 during the English Folk Dance Society Festival. She was accompanied on the piano by her sister, Anne.
There are a number of versions of the Six
Studies in the R.V.W. catalogue including for solo violin, viola and clarinet.
In 1957 Arnold Foster (1896/8-1963) made an attractive arrangement for cello
and small orchestra.
Listen to Vaughan Williams’s Six Studies in English
Folk Song on YouTube, here. The performers are
Denise Djokic (cello), David Jalbert (piano).
With thanks to the English Music Festival where this was first published.
The film has faded into obscurity, but RVW was impressed by the score and drew on it to make a Suite (1945). There are seven movements in all, lasting just under half an hour. The entire suite has been recorded before, on the Chandos and Marco Polo labels. On this album, the BBC Scottish Orchestra under Graham Treacher play just three movements. The first, Dawn in the Old Barn: The Passing of Lovers, is in the composer’s full blown pastoral manner, a delight. Much more sombre is The Dead Man’s Kit, which is lean and desolate, nodding towards the Symphony No.6. The final movement on this disc is In the Café, which the liner notes suggest is composed in a “popular musical idiom.” It is fun, even if conceived in less than happy circumstances. The listener may wish to enjoy this short suite simply as absolute music, divorced from the film’s plot. It could make a successful concert filler and go on to become popular.
There are currently eight recordings of Vaughan Williams’s Phantasy Quintet in the catalogues. I first heard it played by the Music Group of London on the EMI recording issued in 1974 (HQS 1327). There, it was coupled with the Sonata in A minor for violin and piano, as well as the Six Studies in English Folk Song for Cello and Piano. It has remained in my collection ever since. The Phantasy was a W.W. Cobbett commission completed in 1912. It was responding to Cobbett’s desire to revive the historic, single-movement English Elizabethan "fancy," which generated many chamber works by British composers both well-known and now largely forgotten.
Vaughan Williams’s Phantasy Quintet (1912) is a warm, reflective chamber piece that moves in one continuous sweep rather than separate movements, unified by a central theme - although the tracks on this CD are divided into four "sections." The mood shifts naturally between calm and wistful passages, from the deeply felt Alla Sarabanda to playful moments in the Burlesca, all influenced by RVW’s predilection for flowing melodies and folk-coloured harmonies. The Aeolian Quartet, with Kenneth Essex as second viola give an engaging performance that highlights both the Phantasy’s lyrical gentleness and its more spirited moments with unfussy assurance.
Even though some critics find Hodie structurally diffuse and uneven, calling it “overlong” and “one of RVW’s least compelling large choral works,” I love it. Ever since first hearing it on the BBC on Christmas Eve 1972, it has remained one of my seasonal fixtures. This very recording is the source of the extract heard on this disc. The Oxen, a wonderfully evocative Christmas poem by the agnostic Thomas Hardy, is beautifully served here: baritone John Carol Case and the Philomusica of London, under Donald Cashmore, give a suitably sensitive performance.
Vaughan Williams wrote precious little for the organ, despite having been a professional church organist in his younger days. The most significant example is the rarely heard Prelude and Fugue in C minor, dating from 1930; most of the other works associated with him are arrangements by other hands.
It is not certain what instrument
the legendary George Thalben Ball used when recording RVW’s Three Preludes
Founded on Welsh Hymn Tunes. Nevertheless, it is assumed that he played
them on the Temple Church’s 1924 Harrison & Harrison organ, originally from
Glen Tanar Castle, Aberdeenshire. Recorded back in 1961, Thalben Ball gives a
convincing account of these three pieces.
There is a sense of the
improvisatory about the first Prelude, Bryn Calfaria. The popular Rhosymedre
is sincere, presenting the gorgeous melody twice in slightly different
arrangements; it is small wonder that it is subtitled “Lovely.” Hyfrydol
forms a powerful and celebratory finale, built on the well‑loved hymn tune
composed by R. H. Prichard.
For listeners who suppose that
this quartet evokes cows and gates, the truth is quite different. In the sleeve
notes for the above-mentioned record, Michael Kennedy advocates that listeners
who regard this quartet as “serene” and “small” show “a grave misunderstanding
of its true significance and nature.” He goes on to suggest that the first
three movements are “permeated by the restless, troubled mood” of the Symphony
No.6 in E minor. The first movement is tense, the Romance: Largo
is “bleak, comfortless” and the Scherzo is “bitter.” The resolution of the
Quartet comes in the final Epilogue which is calm and heart-easing. The present
liner notes are correct in stating that “This second-string quartet is vital to
a thorough understanding of Vaughan Williams’s deeply felt reaction to the
Second World War, feelings which would find their ultimate expression in the
Sixth Symphony of 1947.”
The Aeolian Quartet sympathise
with the various moods of this piece and give a commanding performance,
articulating the quartet’s troubled inner landscape with conviction and
allowing its concluding calm to feel genuinely won.
Ultimately, From Ursula, with Love stands as a deeply touching and essential release that honours Ursula Vaughan Williams’s personal legacy towards her husband. By preserving these rare, previously unreleased archival treasures, Albion Records has given listeners an invaluable gift - making this release a must-have for any Vaughan Williams devotee.
Track Listing:THE COMPOSITIONS OF HOLST INCLUDE OPERAS of which there are four; orchestral music, military band music, choral works, concertos, songs, and part-songs.
The cast numbers but three - Satyavan,
a woodman; Savitri, his wife, and Death. The orchestra consists of two string
quartets, a contra-bass, two flutes, and a cor anglais. Orchestra, conductor,
and female chorus are to be invisible to the audience. The character of this
article is not suitable for analytical and technical details, so I will not
detain the reader on this account, but the foregoing particulars of Savitri may
help to show the independence and originality of Holst, even in his early
music. Few composers could afford to be daring enough to risk their imagination
on the exotic material of an Indian epic without passing into commonplace,
imitation Orientalism; still less could they invest it with that hallmark of
genius, universality.
The Planets is a suite of seven contrasted movements expressing the character of the mythical associations of their titles, Mars, Venus, Mercury, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune. Produced, with the exception of Venus and Neptune, by the Royal Philharmonic Society, London, on February 27, 1919, it is the work that made Holst. All through we see the undoubted work of a man big enough to make his ideas go. The contrasts between the movements are remarkable. For instance, in Mars, the bringer of War, brutal force is terribly realistic, while in Jupiter, the bringer of Jollity, there are glorious open-air tunes that are musical tonics.
Another interesting orchestral
work by Holst is his Japanese Suite, but it does not reach the high-water
mark of The Planets. The latest music from his pen is announced as a Fugal
Overture and a Fugal Concerto for flute, oboe, and strings, mostly
written during the composer’s voyage home from America this summer. [5] It will
be interesting to hear Holst’s fugues, but a touch of the unconventional
appears in the combination of the concerto.
[2] Savitri was first
performed privately on 5 December 1916, at the London School of Opera under the
conductor Hermann Grunebaum. The premiere public performance was on 23 June
1921, at the Lyric Theatre, Hammersmith. The work was conducted by Arthur Bliss.
[3] A Thematic Catalogue of
Gustav Holst’s Music prepared by Imogen Holst refers to it as an “Opera di
camera in one act.”
[4] To be sure, Holst’s opera The
Perfect Fool has not been a notable success, with few revivals. The opera’s
libretto is awkward and satirical in a way that audiences find puzzling.
However, the Suite of Ballet Music assembled in 1918 remains popular.
[5] Holst returned from the New
York on 21 June 1923, arriving at Plymouth aboard the Belgenland. The
1923 American visit ran from mid‑April to mid‑June 1923, centred on a
University of Michigan residency in Ann Arbor, where he lectured, rehearsed
student ensembles, conducted his own works, and completed the Fugal Concerto.
The surviving published sources give partial but reliable outlines of the dates
and activities, though no fully itemised “programme” survives.
[6] There is no mention in any
authoritative source of Thomas Weelkes being an influence on The Hymn of
Jesus. Holst’s Elizabethan interests tended to centre on Byrd and Tallis,
and even then, they influenced his modal thinking rather than this specific
work. Michael Short writes: “According to Richard Capell, (Monthly Musical
Record February 1927 p.38-9) Holst stated that The Hymn of Jesus had been
written under the influence of Weelkes’ madrigals published in Fellowes’s
edition of 1916, but little evidence of this can be heard in the music.
‘Introduction to The Hymn of Jesus’. (Short, Michael (1990). Gustav
Holst: The Man and His Music. Oxford: Oxford University Press).
[7] At the time of writing there
were no serious piano pieces. The next few years would see a handful of pieces
including the Toccata (1924), A Piece for Yvonne (1924), Chrissemas
Day in the Morning (1926), 2 Folk Song Fragments: 2 Northumbrian Folk
Tunes (1927) and 2 Pieces: Nocturne and Jig (1930-32).
Concluded
The Musical Courier was a famous weekly music magazine published in New York City from 1880 until 1962. It was one of the most widely read music journals in the United States, covering classical performance, industry trade news, and instrument manufacturing.
In this essay, Holst emerges as a modest, hard‑working composer‑teacher whose originality, folk‑inflected directness and independence from academic convention underpin his rise to fame. Porte sketches his personality, teaching at Morley and St Paul’s, his unconventional operas, major orchestral works - especially The Planets - and choral achievements, portraying a modern British composer speaking “big things in plain language.”
A few notes are appended at the
end of the essay.
THE RISE TO FAME OF GUSTAV HOLST gives us a human life story of a great composer happening in our midst. For he is here today, this intensely human man, teaching young people music, correcting their exercises at a school situated in a poor part of London, and yet creating music of his own that is now being everywhere acknowledged as undoubtedly the work of an important man.
[2] The Frankfurt Group comprised
of Balfour Gardiner, Norman O’Neill, Cyril Scott, Roger Quilter and Percy Grainger,
then young composers who studied with the German composer and music teacher
Iwan Knorr during the 1890s. United by friendship and a rebellious, anti‑establishment
streak, they resisted English musical nationalism and favoured Delius’s
harmonic sensuality over Beethovenian architecture.
[3] In the early 1920s Morley
College operated out of the Royal Victoria Hall (the Old Vic) at 131-137
Waterloo Road, London. In 1924 it moved to new premises at 61 Westminster
Bridge Road, where it remains to this day. It is certainly not “squalid” in
2026. The area around the Old Vic has vibrant restaurants, pubs, and cafes.
[4] The “Rush to Hear Holst” was
the headline of a column in the Daily Express (4 September 1923, p.10) where it
was noted that at a performance of The Planets, Gustav Holst had “created
something of a record: he is a serious composer who “draws.” This occurred
during the Promenade Concert on 28 August 1923, where The New Queen’s Hall
Orchestra under Sir Henry Wood played four movements of the work: Mars,
Venus, Mercury, and Jupiter.
[5] Holst was in Constantinople
at the end of the First World War because he had been appointed a Y.M.C.A.
musical organiser for British troops in the Eastern Mediterranean, teaching
music and directing soldier ensembles in Salonika and later Constantinople. His
letters describe giving concerts for demobilising forces and organising musical
life amid difficult conditions.
To be continued...
Wong then presents two attractive
vignettes by Gustave Samazeuilh: the Prelude and the Française
taken from the Suite in G published around 1911. Its six ‘antique’
movements are no Baroque pastiche but a modern re‑imagining of the form, akin
to Ravel’s Tombeau de Couperin or Warlock’s Capriol.
Frank Bridge’s Valse capricieuse from Three Sketches (1906) is one of his loveliest numbers, though the first and second, April and Rosemary, are better known. The Valse is melancholy, more at home in an Edwardian drawing room, yet full of musical and technical interest. Aline Piboule brings her magic to it, illuminating its gentle sadness and subtle technical sparkle. Of exceptional interest is Guy Ropartz’s substantial Nocturne No.1 (1911) with its balance between a severe opening and a lyrical middle section crowned by an “imposing” lead up to the quiet coda. Ropartz provides a fusion of Post-Romanticism and Impressionism in these pages. Certainly, anyone expecting Chopin or Field-like figurations will be disappointed.
The French composer Cécile Chaminade is often written off as simply a writer of ‘salon music,’ but her best work shows a technical assurance and emotional range that far exceed that lazy label. She is well represented on this disc. Roland Pöntinen plays the “elaborated” version of Les Sylvains, op.60 (1892) whose lovely melody and rich accompaniment are offset by contrasting material full of broken chords, arpeggios, and glissandi. The title refers to “fauns,” lending it an elusive, delicate mood. Mark Viner offers Chaminade’s L’Ondine, op.101 (1900), and Pêcheurs de nuit from the Poème provençal, op.127 (1908). The former is hardly a companion to Ravel’s eponymous creation, yet the liner notes suggest that the “delicate passages which frame the piece” portray the water‑nymph Ondine, while the “louder sections concern the sea‑god Poseidon.” Pêcheurs de nuit opens with an uneasily calm atmosphere before moving into a stormy middle section.
Franz Liszt’s Hymne à Sainte Cécile de Charles Gounod, S.491(1865) transcribes an instrumental piece originally scored for solo violin, harp, organ, and orchestra. It is unlikely Liszt’s transcription was ever heard with any frequency until Leslie Howard’s monumental complete recordings of the piano music. I am not a fan of Gounod, but in this work, Liszt deployed all the tricks of his trade to create a vast structure, given a most convincing account by Mark Viner.
Daniel Grimwood plays Adolf Henselt’s lovely transcription of a long-forgotten Romance (No. 1) by a certain Comte Wielhorsky. It is a well-balanced realization that fuses the original accompaniment and the vocal line into a delightful whole. His other contributions to this disc are two of Carl Baermann Jr.’s Études, op. 4 (1877), specifically No. 2 in A minor and No. 12 in C‑sharp minor. This final Étude is especially ambitious with propelling figurations that are both dramatic and charged with suppressed urgency.
American composer Amy Beach’s A Hermit Thrush at Eve, op. 92 no. 1 (pub. 1922), is played by Saskia Giorgini, and distils accurately notated birdsong into glowing, impressionistic piano writing, creating a contemplative miniature of striking poetic delicacy.
Two short pieces by the Polish pianist-composer Ignaz Paderewski are given by Illia Ovcharenko. Chant d’amour, the second movement from his Album de Mai, op. 10 (pub.1884), contrasts a folksong-like opening with an animated middle section. In Cracovienne fantastique from Humoresques de concert, op. 14 Cahier II, (1887-88), Paderewski uses triplets, octaves, chromatic runs, and neat figurations to create a spirited reimagining of the regional folk style.
The final number in this recital is also my favourite. Ronald Stevenson made countless arrangements and transcriptions of a wide range of “found” music, including popular songs. Ivor Novello wrote his well‑loved “We’ll Gather Lilacs in the Spring” for the stage show Perchance to Dream. Here, Stevenson gives this cherished tune the full cocktail‑piano treatment. Kenneth Hamilton dispatches it with panache.
Peter Grove’s liner notes, in both German and English, are helpful, offering valuable background on these rarely encountered composers and their music. One minor erratum: the liner notes state Frank Bridge was born in 1897 rather than 1879. And surely the recording dates are wrong. The rear cover states 16-21August, 2025, but the actual concert prospectus shows that it was 16-23 August that year!
This latest volume from Husum once again demonstrates why the festival remains indispensable for anyone drawn to the byways of the piano repertoire. The performances are consistently distinguished, the programming imaginative, and the recorded sound remarkably vivid for live conditions. Together they offer a compelling reminder that the piano’s literature extends far beyond the familiar canon, rewarding curiosity with discovery at every turn.
Track Listing: