Wrapping up my discussion of Bowen's Second, Stanford's Seventh and Parry's Fifth Symphonies it is useful to present a current discography of these works.
Like
all works of art, these three symphonies seem to attract a wide range of
critical views. However one thing can be clear: all three are commendable works
that add considerably to the stock of British symphonies. As noted throughout
these last three posts all three works have been criticised as being both derivative and
not ‘avant-garde’. However, what strikes the reader of contemporary and more
recent reviews of these works is the general consensus that Bowen, Parry and
Stanford have produced works that may not be their masterpieces (Parry
excepted) but are technically competent and emotionally satisfying. Each
symphony deserves its place in the repertoire and ought to be heard at symphony
orchestra concerts. However, this is unlikely to happen when the public have an
insatiable demand for Tchaikovsky, Beethoven and Mahler. At least all three
works are committed to recordings and these will be available for a very long
time: these CDs are unlikely to be
superseded for very many years.
From
a personal point of view, all three works impress me: the sheer classical poise
of Stanford, the personal soul searching, and often Elgarian mood of the Parry
and the youthfulness and panache of the Bowen.
Discography
York
Bowen: Symphony No. 2 in E minor, Op. 31 (with orchestral works by Frederic
Austin and Edgar Bainton) CLASSICO CLASSCD404 (2002)
Royal
Northern College of Music Symphony Orchestra conducted by Douglas Bostock.
York
Bowen: Symphony No. 2 in E minor, Op. 31 (with Symphony No.1) CHANDOS CHAN
10670 (2011)
BBC
Philharmonic conducted by Sir Andrew Davis
Hubert
Parry: Symphony No. 5 in B minor "Symphonic Fantasia 1912" EMI
65107 (1987, 1994) (original LP release of: EMI ASD 3725) (1979) (with
Symphonic Variations, Elegy for Brahms and Blest Pair of Sirens)
London Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Sir Adrian Boult
London Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Sir Adrian Boult
Hubert
Parry: Symphony No. 5 in B minor ‘Symphonic Fantasia 1912’ CHANDOS CHAN 8955 (1991) (with From
Death to Life & Elegy for Brahms)
London
Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Matthias Bamert
Charles Villiers Stanford: Symphony No. 7 in D minor, Op. 124 NAXOS 8.570285 (2007) (with Symphony No. 4)
Charles Villiers Stanford: Symphony No. 7 in D minor, Op. 124 NAXOS 8.570285 (2007) (with Symphony No. 4)
Bournemouth
Symphony Orchestra conducted by David Lloyd-Jones
Charles Villiers Stanford: Symphony No. 7 in D minor, Op. 124 CHANDOS CHAN 8861 (1990) (with Irish Rhapsody No. 3 and Concert Piece)
Ulster Orchestra conducted by Vernon Handley
Charles Villiers Stanford: Symphony No. 7 in D minor, Op. 124 CHANDOS CHAN 8861 (1990) (with Irish Rhapsody No. 3 and Concert Piece)
Ulster Orchestra conducted by Vernon Handley
No comments:
Post a Comment