Finger Prints: British Light Music for Piano

The ethos of this pot-pourri is predicated on an old Viennese adage of “taking serous music lightly and light music seriously.” Here the listener will find an “eclectic” selection from a wide cross section of composers. These include pieces by so-called “classical” masters such as Frank Bridge, John Ireland, Roger Quilter, and Lennox Berkeley. These men were able to cross the boundaries between art music and a more “popular” touch. The recital gets off to a great start with Harry Engleman’s Finger Prints. This is the epitome of the novelty piano solo made so popular by Billy Mayerl (more of him later in the review) and the American Zez Confrey. Later in the programme we hear Engleman’s Golden Chain, another challenging piece for “dizzy fingers.”

Haydn Wood is usually remembered for his First World War hit, Roses of Picardy. Capable of working in both light and classical genres, he wrote accomplished piano and violin concertos, as well as attractively evocative orchestral suites. Longing is delightfully sentimental, poignant, at times passionate and always engaging. Written in 1917, it well reflects the emotions of wartime lovers.

I enjoyed Cecil Macklin’s The Cockney Crawl, which was originally danced at the Alhambra Theatre, London by Phyllis Monkman and Clyde Cook. Basically, a one or two-step with knobs on!

All enthusiasts of so-called light music will know Jack Strachey’s In Party Mood, used for many years as the theme tune for the radio programme Housewife’s Choice. Equally popular is his Theatreland, so reminiscent of London’s West End. Anna’s Polka is a lovely little number that combines the Bohemian dance of the title with a beguine. Paul Guinery adds a little “quirky” magic of his own in the concluding bars.

When I inherited my late grandparents’ upright, there was a copy of Amy Woodforde-Finden’s Indian Love Lyrics in the piano stool. I struggled to battle my way through the Kashmiri Love Song from an early age, never quite getting it right. The mood is of lost love, nostalgia, and despair, as seen through the eyes of an Edwardian lady’s enthusiasm for things ‘Oriental.’ It is heard here in Stephen Hough’s transcription.

Billy Mayerl was an English pianist and composer, popular in the 1930s. He is best remembered for his syncopated novelty piano solos like Marigold and Bats in the Belfry. His music was “highly crafted,” often cunningly difficult to play and always entertaining. He is represented on this disc by four arrangements of songs written for Hollywood by the British born songwriter, Harry Revel. Most popular is the jazzed-up version of Did You Ever See a Dream Walking? Equally attractive is I Feel Like a Feather in The Breeze with its lush opening and bouncy middle sections. With My Eyes Wide Open I’m Dreaming appeared in film about a successful nightclub singer and radio star. Once again Mayerl creates a balance between a slow foxtrot and an up-tempo section marked “with much rhythm.” The final transcription is the well-crafted You Hit the Spot from the film Collegiate (1936). The one original composition is The Shy Ballerina, which is a wistful celebration of a bashful girl who was asked to dance for Mayerl, but “nothing would persuade her to pirouette for him.” All are marked by rhythmic dash, memorable melodies, abundant caprice, and a touch of sheer sentimentality.

Edward German was an English composer of Welsh descent. He is known for his extensive output of incidental music for the stage. His light operas, including Merrie England, hold a place still in the repertoire. German also wrote symphonies, orchestral suites, and some piano pieces. The Polish Dance nods to the Chopin’s Mazurkas and is none the worse for that. It balances high spirits with more reflective moments.

Frank Bridge’s Berceuse was dished up in several editions, including for small orchestra, violin or cello and piano, violin and strings, and a late addition in 1929, as a piano solo. This exquisite lullaby features a delicate, calming tune that perfectly lives up to its title. In true Frank Bridge fashion, it transcends the boundaries of mere salon music, revealing layers of subtlety and elegant craftsmanship.

Two works are heard by cinema pianist and broadcaster Jack Wilson. Phantom Fingers ticks all the boxes of “novelty, syncopated or rhythmic piano solos.” It is his only published piece. The second, still in manuscript, is the undated Shadows on the Moon. It fairly swings along, with little gloom in these pages.

Cavatina by John Ireland has had numerous incarnations. Originally produced in 1904 for organ, and violin and piano, it “shows that Ireland had a gift for melody in the style of say Elgar’s Salut d’amour or Chanson de Matin”.

Transitioning from violinist to rhythm pianist, Peggy Cochrane, wrote Busy Day in 1941. This lively item highlights a jazzy left hand and a delightful, almost mischievous, flurry of notes in the right hand.

Roger Quilter is recalled for his incomparable songs. There are a few pieces for piano, including Three Studies and Three English Dances. The present Country Dance is from incidental music for the 1921-22 Old Vic production of Shakespeare’s As You Like It. Grainger-esque, it uses “off beat rhythms” and “teasing counter melodies.”

Arthur Sullivan is usually paired with W.S. Gilbert in peoples’ minds. Yet in recent years, his non-Savoy-Opera music has gained a hearing, especially in the recording studio. He did not produce many piano works: the liner notes state that there are only nine original pieces published in his lifetime. The two Thoughts here date from 1862 and clearly have a debt to Felix Mendelssohn. They are full of melodic charm and pianistic delight.

One work that may surprise the listener is Lennox Berkeley’s Java. This parody was written in 1932 and was originally part of an unrealised ballet score. Lots of wrong notes and chords here (think Les Dawson!) and a good impression of the “salacious” dance that was the rage in post war Paris in 1919. The arrangement here was made by composer, historian, and pianist, the late Peter Dickinson.

The final track on this charming CD is Richard Addinsell’s Blithe Spirit Waltz, taken from the eponymous 1945 film starring Rex Harrison, Kay Hammond, and Constance Cummings. This was a supernatural, black comedy derived from Noel Coward’s stage play. The Waltz is a wonderful evocation of Elvira (Hammond), Charles’s (Harrison) first wife, who is summoned at a seance.

The CD booklet is a model in design. Beginning with a brief outline of each composer, in alphabetical order, this is followed by succinct comments on each work in batting order. They are clear to read. Illustrations of sheet music covers enhance the impact of this insert. A note on the soloist is included.

This is the third CD in Paul Guinery’s exploration of light music classics. In 2020 he released Dicky Bird Hop (reviewed, here, and here) and two years later Chasing Moonbeams. (Sadly, not yet assessed for MusicWeb International).

Tremendous playing by Paul Guinery, an outstanding recording, and splendid packaging contribute to the success of this CD. Each piece is played with love and enthusiasm, and is never condescending, which is the way that light music ought to be performed.

Track Listing:
Harry Engleman (1912–2002)
Finger Prints (1936)
Haydn Wood (1882–1959)
Longing (1917)
Cecil Macklin (1883–1944)
The Cockney Crawl (1914)
Jack Strachey (1894–1972)
Anna’s Polka (date unknown)
Amy Woodforde-Finden (1860–1919)
Kashmiri Song (1902) (Trans. Stephen Hough, b.1962)
Harry Revel (1905–1958)
Did You Ever See a Dream Walking? (1933) (Trans. Billy Mayerl)
I Feel Like a Feather in The Breeze (1936) (Trans. Billy Mayerl)
Edward German (1862–1936)
Polish Dance (1891)
Harry Engleman
Golden Chain (1937)
Frank Bridge (1879–1941)
Berceuse (1901)
Jack Wilson (1907–2006)
Phantom Fingers (1934)
John Ireland (1879–1962)
Cavatina (1904)
Peggy Cochrane (1902–1988)
Busy Day (1941)
Harry Revel
With My Eyes Wide Open I’m Dreaming (1934) (Trans. Billy Mayerl)
You Hit the Spot (1936) (Trans. Billy Mayerl)
Roger Quilter (1877–1953)
Country Dance (1920)
Arthur Sullivan (1842–1900)
Thoughts, op. 2 No. 1 (1862)
Thoughts, op. 2 No. 2 (1862)
Jack Wilson
Shadows On the Moon (date unknown)
Billy Mayerl (1902–1959)
Shy Ballerina (1948)
Lennox Berkeley (1903–1989)
Java (1932) (Trans. Peter Dickinson, 1934-2023)
Richard Addinsell (1904–1977)
Blithe Spirit Waltz (1945)
Paul Guinery (piano)
rec. 4-5 January 2024, St John the Evangelist Church, Oxford
EM Records EMR CD088